NHL Picks / Oct 19, 2026

NHL Predictions Today: Picks for Monday, October 19, 2026

We post on the early lines, hours before lineups and starting goalies are confirmed. If a key player is ruled out, or someone important returns, factor that in before you bet.

Pick of the day No bet

San Jose Sharks vs Toronto Maple Leafs Prediction

Our tip is the Sharks, the underdog here. The Maple Leafs are reportedly missing Chris Tanev and John Tavares. Toronto's recent play has also trailed San Jose's. We have the Sharks at 36.6% in regulation, so 2.95 is a price worth taking.

Sharks to win in regulation
best odds 2.95 at publication · 4 units

Condition: Only if Sergei Bobrovsky starts in goal for Toronto. If Anthony Stolarz starts, there is no bet. Check the confirmed starter before you bet: Daily Faceoff's starting goalies page usually has it after the morning skate. Update: Bobrovsky is confirmed, but the price has dropped to 2.80 and the case now hangs on William Nylander, a game-time decision for Toronto. At this price we pass: no bet.

Our 60-minute probabilities

1 Maple Leafs40.4%fair odds 2.47
X Draw23.0%fair odds 4.35
2 Sharks36.6%fair odds 2.73

Anaheim Ducks vs New York Rangers Prediction

Our numbers favor the Rangers at home.

Our 60-minute probabilities

1 Rangers45.0%fair odds 2.22
X Draw23.2%fair odds 4.31
2 Ducks31.8%fair odds 3.15

No pick in this game.

Colorado Avalanche vs Philadelphia Flyers Prediction

Our numbers clearly favor the Avalanche on the road. The Avalanche were the league's best regular-season team a year ago with 121 points.

Our 60-minute probabilities

1 Flyers18.2%fair odds 5.51
X Draw20.2%fair odds 4.94
2 Avalanche61.6%fair odds 1.62

No pick in this game.

Pittsburgh Penguins vs Utah Mammoth Prediction

We make the Mammoth clear favorites at home.

Our 60-minute probabilities

1 Mammoth51.5%fair odds 1.94
X Draw22.6%fair odds 4.43
2 Penguins26.0%fair odds 3.85

No pick in this game.

Results

Regulation picks are settled on the 60-minute result, moneyline picks on the game winner (overtime and shootout included). Full record: track record.

Our probabilities are for the first 60 minutes, with the fair odds that match them. Odds are the best price we found across major EEA-licensed bookmakers at publication; compare with your own licensed bookmaker. 18+, bet responsibly.